What does your tongue have to do with your maximum strength?!

As neuroathletics coaches, we focus on the various forms of input received by the human brain. This refers to all sensory information that reaches the brain from the external and internal worlds via the body’s sensors. As is well known, any input, accompanied by its interpretation in the brain, has the potential to alter the output. However, if the data quality from an input sensor is poor, the interpretation of that data in the relevant area of the brain will consequently suffer. What we then do is simply reintegrate this sensor into the system and calibrate it. So much for the theory. In reality, of course, we are dealing with biological structures, and the situation is far more complex.
Pilot study raises questions
However, the (pilot) study ‘The acute effect of the tongue position in the mouth on knee isokinetic test performance: a highly surprising pilot study’ impressively demonstrates the power of input in relation to output. Tongue position and strength performance? Whilst this may sound confusing at first, there is a rational basis for it. But first things first: squat strength was compared between two groups. The control group was asked to perform the squat on the isokinetic machine without any further intervention, whilst the second group did the same but with a small modification: All participants were asked to press their tongue upwards against the roof of their mouth during the muscle test. Lo and behold: significant improvements were recorded across all performance-related parameters. Squat strength increased by an average of over 30 per cent. Of course, this is initially a pilot study, so further important research is still to come. Nevertheless, one should be aware of the possible implications: If a 30 per cent (!) increase in strength can be generated simply through tongue position, how seriously can we take past strength training studies? Any study that does not specify the exact tongue position in its protocol could therefore have been subject to bias.
From a neurological perspective, the results make sense: in order to keep the tongue in its natural position (with the entire tongue resting against the palate), a significant number of nuclei in the brainstem (medulla oblongata) must be activated, and their signals transmitted via the cranial nerves to the tongue muscles. The tongue is therefore a good indicator of brain activity because it is motor-innervated by two cranial nerves, CN X and XII, meaning that tongue movements can activate virtually the entire medulla. In addition, other parts of the brainstem in the pons and medulla provide sensory innervation to the tongue. If we look further at the motor homunculus, what strikes us about this odd-looking fellow is that he has enormous hands, lips and an oversized tongue. Consequently, a correspondingly large amount of cortical storage space is required for these enlarged body parts. Movement of the tongue can therefore activate large parts of the motor cortex. The brainstem and the cortex simultaneously! Wow! The mechanism behind why the flexor muscles became so strong in the study might also lie in the medulla: As part of the brainstem, this is primarily responsible for maintaining tone in the flexor muscles. When all the cranial nerves described – which control the tongue muscles – fire, the flexor muscles are also activated.
Oh yes, and what’s more, an active tongue position leads to mechanical stabilisation of the head and cervical spine, as the three tongue muscles are directly connected to the neck and cervical muscles. This is absolutely crucial during sprints and jumps to ensure active spinal stability and thereby reduce protective reflex activity! When you look at it all together, the tongue is therefore a powerful tool for modulating motor output.
A brief example of the Input-Interpretation-Output model
Let’s return to the Input-Interpretation-Output model: if the tongue alone can have such an enormous effect on output, what happens when the eyes are in different positions? You guessed it: EVERY TIME the eyes move, the force output potentially changes! Yet another (seemingly) minor detail that wasn’t controlled for in the study design. Try it for yourselves: stand upright, bring your heel towards your buttocks and ask someone to test the strength of your hamstrings. Do this strength test with your eyes in a neutral position; on the second attempt, look down (but don’t move your head); and on the third attempt, look up. Then try the same little experiment with your tongue pressed firmly against the roof of your mouth. If the back of your thighs start to cramp almost instantly, this information will be very useful to you, as a cramping muscle is probably not exactly the strongest muscle in your body. Consequently, this muscle can and should be trained, using tongue and eye position as additional stimuli.
Conclusion
It appears that strength performance is highly dynamic and depends on more than just hypertrophy and fibre distribution. We should be cautious when interpreting studies as long as the study design does not clearly control for the various inputs. We’ll see what the future brings.
Source: Pilot study
Di Vico, R., Ardigò, L. P., Salernitano, G., Chamari, K., & Padulo, J. (2013). The acute effect of the tongue position in the mouth on knee isokinetic test performance: a highly surprising pilot study. Muscles, Ligaments and Tendons Journal, 3(4), 318–323.


